A Passion for Running

Welcome to the home of Mark aka The Running Blogfather – a 40 year-old dad, husband and marathon runner who's beaten injury and is on the comeback trail!

this is buggin’ me

passion for running category: running on Monday, May 9 2005

Let me preface this post by saying some people (probably a select few people) have perfect or near-perfect running form and never/rarely get injuries. This post does not apply to those lucky…ducks. It is also not suggesting you should change your running form. It’s purpose is simply to take issue with something that’s been on my mind lately
——————–

Over the last several weeks I’ve happened upon comments on the web which I just don’t understand, don’t agree with and which are starting to bug me. ;)

The phrasing is usually something along these lines…

You should not try to change your running form because it is ‘natural’ and attempts to change it will probably cause more harm than good.

Wat-choo talkin’ bout’ Willis?

So, do we get rid of every coach who works on running form or do we recognize there must be a good reason(s) why coaches work on form?

While I agree it’s entirely probable that many children run with a healthy, natural form, I think it’s also just as likely that just as many adults learn or adopt poor form. In essence, I think it’s highly likely that adults often knowingly or unknowingly change their natural running form and, because of this, often need to change it back to a more natural form.

How does an adult learn or adopt poor running form? Let’s look at a couple examples how it can happen:

1-You take a learn to run class where the coach/leader/instructor tells you that in order to run distance, you should land on your heels and roll forward so you work on that and, over time, become a heel striker.

2-You get injured and subconsciously modify your form to protect yourself from the injury or the possibility of injuring yourself again and the modification becomes part of your gait.

Case in point: I suffered a medial (inner) ankle stress fracture in my last marathon. Months later, I was experiencing some pain while running. Then, I realized I was landing on the outer side of my foot in order to avoid landing on the inner part of my right foot. The modification was almost totally subconscious and began to cause me problems. I was lucky enough to realize this since I could have easily normalized it as part of my gait and may very well have gone on to cause myself more problems.

Another example: Aaron sprained his ankle over ten years ago. His physiotherapist noted recently that this was the likely cause of his knee injuries. Why? Because the old injury had never been corrected and had caused major imbalances in his running form.

Are we to accept that our current running form is our natural form and that it should not be changed or is it possible we’ve learned or adopted bad running form which can/should be corrected?

If running form is natural then why do two-thirds of runners suffer from injuries each year? Is that natural?

Lotsa questions huh? Do you have any thoughts or answers you’d like to share?




12 Comments

Comment by Dawn (aka Pink Lady)

Monday May 09, 2005 @

In the clinic I went to a couple of weeks ago, it was mentioned that one injury can lead to other issues. And an unadressed issue can crop up as an injury elsewhere. He demonstrated how while the muscles, etc are separate, each has adjoining areas so stress on one can actually result on injuries appearing elsewhere.

Myself as of late, the center of my heals have been bothering me after a run. No aches when running but after I remove my shoes and attempt to walk barefoot I can barely put any weight on them. Even more so the next morning but it fades after a day or so. I suspect my runners may be the problem or perhaps I need some more cushioning type insoles. Or is it my form – heal strike? Any ideas?

Comment by Mark

Monday May 09, 2005 @

Dawn, that TOTALLY sounds like Plantar Fasciitis. I know because I had it several years ago. Here are a couple of links.

http://completerunning.com/dr.miller/?p=12

http://heelspurs.com/index.html

Please take care of that Pink Lady. :)

Comment by Karen in Calgary

Monday May 09, 2005 @

I changed my form just an eensy bit last summer and it did me a world of good. I suffered from early stages of PF and found that leaning forward from the ankles and NOT LANDING ON MY HEELS helped. It not only made me faster, but my feet felt better. The change in form caused a few blisters at first, because my feet had to develop callouses in different places, but it was worth it just to make that little change. I also changed my shoes to one with a less prominent heel cup.

I’m still working on my calves and hamstrings by trying to take smaller strides, and do ankle and foot exercises every day to keep the PF muscle supple.

Remind me, Dawn, to show you those exercises tomorrow.

As for form being “natural”? That’s a bunch of hooey. Running has technique, just like learning to swing a bat, catch a ball, or stop a puck.

Comment by BD

Monday May 09, 2005 @

It annoys me when I see websites stating that one shouldn’t try to change running form. Natural form does equal good form. It true for all sports. We can all throw naturally but there is a best way to throw a javelin, football, and baseball. We can all jump naturally but there is a best way to high jump or long jump. We can all punch naturally but most people have miserable striking form before they take martial arts. So it is with running. There is an effective, efficient form and it surely does not involve striking with the heel first. Anyone who leans forward slightly (as you should do when running) and then puts the leg out in front so that the heel can strike first, going into a “rolling” motion, can immediately tell that the body mechanics are all screwed up. You can fight gravity and momentum. You have to work with them.

So yes, I’m totally with you about the form. But I’m still wearing my shoes.

Comment by BD

Monday May 09, 2005 @

My post has a typo.

“Natural form does equal good form.” should read “Natural form does NOT equal good form.”

Comment by BD

Monday May 09, 2005 @

I’m tired. Another error. Near the bottom it should read:

You CAN’T fight gravity and momentum.

Comment by Mark

Monday May 09, 2005 @

Thank you Karen and BD. Well said.

And BD, I won’t make you take off your shoes as long as we can agree that more and more structure in shoes is NOT the answer. ;)

Comment by Jon in Michigan

Tuesday May 10, 2005 @

I’ve always had a perfect running form and I think that’s why I have never had running injuries. I have a “friend” who has had alot of trouble with shin splints and ITBS.

I think people change their form more often than they know. Even get that advice to “pump your arms harder to get up the hill”? Congratulations, you just changed your running form. What about “taking longer/shorter strides going downhill”? Congratulations, you did it again. Stand more upright and don’t bend over when you run? That’s three.

People see these changes as “temporary” for certain circumstances and don’t count as part of their “form”. Its ALL part of their form, they just don’t know it. Arms, torso, legs, back – it all makes the full form and anything they do to them, is going to change their form.

Don’t change your form? Egads! That next hill is going to kill you.

Comment by Mary

Tuesday May 10, 2005 @

When I finally made the decision to run, I knew that I had better learn how to do it “right”. I knew from my old racewalking gang that they considered running a high risk sport. I remember one of them telling me that runners are prone to all sorts of injuries, but racewalkers were not. I remembered that and decided to investigate it for myself. That’s when I ran across completerunning.com and followed the link to the Pose Method. Although, I haven’t mastered the Pose Method as of yet, I haven’t sustained any injuries either(to God be the glory).

Comment by Reba

Tuesday May 10, 2005 @

Well if I never thought about the subject before then after reading Dr Romanov’s book it’s all I think about. Once I was aware of how my form is causing tremendous, damaging impact I became all about changing it. What little bit I’m able to grasp so far is helping the PF big time and I’ve not taken an NSAID for my back in over a month! I’m so excited because I’m doing much better already and I’m no where near Mark…I see a brilliant light of beautiful form at the end of my tunnel. I just feel really bad for folks who think changing form is bad and like Jon said, sounds to me like they aren’t even aware of what form really is…dollars to donuts they’ve changed it numerous times consciously without thinking of it as ‘form.’

Comment by beverly

Tuesday May 10, 2005 @

Is running natural? Uhhhhh …. from my my experience, no. I have probably done things a little backwards in that I got out and ran, and thankfully haven’t been injured, but now am looking at form for the first time. It’s all a learning process.

Jon, does your “friend” have a blog?? Focusing on shin splints, appliance delivery, and chocolate, perhaps? You kill me!

Comment by mark

Saturday July 16, 2005 @

i dont agree with perfect running form what is perfect. i think every persons body is different and i think the perfect running form is kind of ment to be universal and sometimes it is benifical for people to diviate from it. for example paula radclif has the world record in the marathon but she has horrible form probably the worst ive ever seen. im not saying that if she fixed her form she wouldnt be better but i dont know how you can get much better than the best in the world

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
A blue box by your comment means you do not have an avatar from www.gravatar.com!

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.